Bargain guide

Best Buy Open-Box: Excellent, Good, Fair

Every Best Buy open-box grade works like new; they differ in looks and what is in the box. Which grade to buy for TVs, laptops and more (October 2026).

By the GuideToBargain teamOct 4, 2026Updated Oct 30, 20267 min read

Woman holding a pair of white over-ear headphones
On this page
  1. What do Best Buy's open-box grades mean?
  2. How much do you save on open-box at Best Buy?
  3. Which open-box grade should you buy?
  4. Laptops: check the charger and the battery
  5. Can you return open-box items to Best Buy?
  6. Do Best Buy open-box items have a warranty?
  7. Open-box vs refurbished vs new at Best Buy
  8. How to shop Best Buy open-box
  9. Best Buy open-box FAQ

Best Buy's three open-box grades all work like new and are restored to factory settings: Excellent also looks like new and has all its parts, Good may have minor scratches and miss non-essential extras, and Fair may have larger dents and miss parts. The lower the grade, the lower the price. Every definition below is Best Buy's own wording, checked in October 2026. For more ways to spend less, see our money saving tips.

What do Best Buy's open-box grades mean?

Best Buy inspects every open-box item, restores it to factory settings where that applies, and prices it by condition. As of October 2026, its Geek Squad verified grades are Excellent, Good and Fair. All three work like new; the grades only describe cosmetic wear and whether the original parts, accessories and packaging are included.

GradeWorks like newLooksParts and packaging
ExcellentYes, restored to factory settingsLike newAll original parts, packaging and accessories, or a suitable replacement
GoodYes, restored to factory settingsMay have minor scratches or dentsMay miss non-essential parts, accessories or original packaging
FairYes, restored to factory settingsMay have larger dents or scratchesMay miss parts and accessories

Open-box items are customer returns, display models or products with damaged packaging. Many were returned only because the first buyer changed their mind.

How much do you save on open-box at Best Buy?

The discount depends on the product and its grade, with no fixed percentage: Excellent is priced closest to new, Fair furthest below. Best Buy Outlet stores advertise savings of up to 40% on Outlet items, including clearance and open-box appliances and TVs, as of October 2026. Always compare the open-box price with the current new price.

That last step matters because new prices move. During a sale, a new item can cost little more than an open-box one, or even less, and new comes sealed with everything in the box.

Which open-box grade should you buy?

Buy Excellent for anything you handle every day or where missing accessories are expensive, such as laptops, tablets and headphones. Good or Fair often make sense for large items where looks do not matter much, such as a TV you will wall-mount or an appliance that sits between cabinets. The right grade depends on the product.

ProductBest gradeWhy
Laptops and tabletsExcellentA missing charger or scratched lid costs money or annoys you daily
Headphones and earbudsExcellentYou want every ear tip, the case and a clean, complete set
TVsGood or FairMarks on the back or stand disappear once mounted; check the screen itself
Major appliancesGood or FairA dent on a side panel between cabinets does not matter
Gaming consolesExcellent or GoodCheck that controllers and cables are included

Whatever the grade, read the listing for what is missing. A Fair TV without its remote or a Good laptop without its charger may cost more to complete than the discount saves.

Laptops: check the charger and the battery

For a laptop, Excellent is usually worth the small extra cost because it includes the original charger and looks new. Once you set it up, check the battery health and register the warranty with the maker. Our guide on how to buy a laptop without overpaying covers the specs that matter.

Can you return open-box items to Best Buy?

Yes. As of October 2026, Best Buy applies the same return and exchange policy to open-box items as to new ones. Most purchases have 15 days, or 60 days for My Best Buy Plus and Total members, and phones and other activatable devices have 14 days. The return period starts on the day you receive the product.

Returns must come back in like-new condition with their contents. Best Buy also charges restocking fees on some categories: $45 for activatable devices such as phones, and 15% for drones, cameras and projectors, unless the box is unopened. An open-box item has by definition been opened, so expect the fee to apply if you return one of those.

Do Best Buy open-box items have a warranty?

In many cases, yes: Best Buy says open-box items often come with the same manufacturer warranty as a new product, as of October 2026. The listing or a Blue Shirt can confirm what an item carries and when the coverage started, so ask before you buy an expensive one. You can also add Geek Squad Protection at checkout.

Register the product with its maker as soon as you get it, and keep your Best Buy receipt with the open-box grade printed on it. If the warranty matters a lot, for example on a laptop or a large TV, ask the store to confirm the coverage in writing.

Open-box vs refurbished vs new at Best Buy

Open-box items are returns and display models graded by wear; refurbished items are restored to like-new condition with all vital parts; new items are sealed with the full warranty. As of October 2026, the online Best Buy Outlet sells both, Outlet stores carry open-box and clearance items, and all of them follow its return promise.

Open-boxRefurbishedNew
What it isReturned or display item, graded Excellent, Good or FairRestored to like-new, all vital parts includedSealed and unused
Cosmetic wearNone to larger dents, by gradeCleaned and inspectedNone
AccessoriesComplete only at ExcellentAll vital partsComplete
Price matchExcludedExcludedMatched against key competitors

Price matching is the hidden difference: Best Buy excludes open-box, refurbished and clearance items from its price match, so a new item can sometimes be matched down to a competitor's lower price instead. For Dell computers specifically, compare our Dell Outlet vs refurbished vs new guide.

How to shop Best Buy open-box

Search the product you want, check its open-box listings by grade, compare with the new price, and pick up in store when you can to inspect it. Best Buy Outlet stores carry open-box and clearance items and can deliver and install open-box major appliances. Timing your purchase around a sale can make new the better price.

  1. Search the exact model and open the open-box options on its page.
  2. Compare each grade with the current new price and any Best Buy discounts.
  3. Read what is missing for Good and Fair items.
  4. Choose store pickup to inspect it before you take it home.
  5. Keep your receipt and register the warranty.

For timing, our guide to the best time to buy electronics shows when new prices drop, and our Black Friday game plan helps you judge holiday sales.

Amazon runs its own version of open box and refurbished sales. Our guide to Amazon Outlet, Resale and Renewed explains its condition grades, the 30-day Resale returns and the 90-day Renewed guarantee, so you can compare the same item at both stores.

Best Buy open-box FAQ

Is open-box Excellent the same as new?

Almost. As of October 2026, Best Buy says an Excellent item works and looks like new, is restored to factory settings, and includes all original parts, packaging and accessories or a suitable replacement. The difference is that it has been opened, often returned by a buyer who changed their mind, so it costs less than a sealed new product.

What is the difference between open-box Good and Fair?

Both work like new and are restored to factory settings. As of October 2026, Good may have minor scratches or dents and may miss non-essential parts, accessories or packaging, while Fair may have larger dents or scratches and may miss parts and accessories. Fair is cheaper, so it suits items where looks matter less, such as a wall-mounted TV.

Can I return an open-box item to Best Buy?

Yes. As of October 2026, open-box items follow the same return policy as new ones: 15 days for most purchases, 60 days for My Best Buy Plus and Total members, and 14 days for phones and other activatable devices. Restocking fees apply to some categories, such as $45 on activatable devices and 15% on drones, cameras and projectors.

Does Best Buy price match open-box items?

No. As of October 2026, Best Buy's price match excludes open-box, refurbished, clearance and Marketplace items. It matches the current price of key competitors only on identical new products. If a competitor sells the same item new for less, a price-matched new item can sometimes beat an open-box one.

Some links in this guide are affiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.