Bargain guide

How to Save on Pet Food and Supplies

Autoship cuts 35% off a first order and 5% after at Chewy and PetSmart. How the programs compare, plus bulk buys and smart swaps, checked October 2026.

By the GuideToBargain teamOct 4, 2026Updated Oct 12, 20266 min read

A dog and a cat cuddling together on the grass
On this page
  1. Chewy vs PetSmart Autoship compared
  2. How much does Autoship really save?
  3. How PetSmart Treats Rewards works
  4. Chewy shipping and returns
  5. Buy the right size and compare price per unit
  6. Smart swaps that save money
  7. Save on pet medication
  8. Pet supplies FAQ

The easiest way to save on pet supplies is a repeat delivery program for the food, litter and treats you buy every few weeks: as of October 2026, both Chewy and PetSmart take 35% off your first Autoship order, up to $20, and 5% off every recurring order after that. Add the right bag size and price-per-pound comparisons, and pet costs drop without any change to your pet's routine. For more ways to spend less, see our money saving tips.

Chewy vs PetSmart Autoship compared

Chewy and PetSmart run nearly identical Autoship discounts: 35% off the first order, capped at $20, then 5% off recurring orders, as of October 2026. PetSmart adds Treats Rewards points on top, including a bonus payout for Autoship spending, while Chewy offers free shipping over $49 and a 365-day return window. Both let you change or cancel deliveries.

ChewyPetSmart
First Autoship order35% off, up to $2035% off, up to $20, one time only
Recurring orders5% off eligible items5% off each qualifying order
Rewards on topNone listedTreats Rewards: 10 points per $1, plus 2,500 bonus points per $100 of recurring Autoship
ShippingFree over $49; $4.95 below; free over $35 on a first orderShip to home, in-store pickup or same-day delivery where available
Returns365 days, with free return shippingStore policy applies
ChangesChange, skip or cancel any timeChange at least 24 hours before an order is placed

Chewy figures were checked on Chewy's site on October 7, 2026, and PetSmart figures on October 12, 2026.

How much does Autoship really save?

On a $60 bag of food, the first Autoship order saves $20 (35% would be $21, but the cap is $20), and every later delivery saves $3 at 5%. Over a year of monthly deliveries, that is about $53 at either store. At PetSmart, Treats Rewards points add roughly another 7% on recurring orders.

$60 bag, delivered monthlyChewyPetSmart
First order discount$20$20
11 recurring orders at 5%$33$33
Rewards points, 11 recurring ordersNone listedAbout $13 in base points plus about $30 in Autoship payout points
Total first yearAbout $53About $96

PetSmart's points math, as of October 2026: 10 points per $1 is worth $2 per 1,000 points, so about 2% back, and the Autoship Points Payout adds 2,500 points, worth $5, for every $100 of recurring Autoship spending, paid four times a year. The first Autoship order does not count toward the payout.

How PetSmart Treats Rewards works

Treats Rewards is PetSmart's free loyalty program. As of October 2026, all members earn 10 points for every $1 spent on products and services, including grooming, PetsHotel, Doggie Day Camp and training, and 1,000 points are worth $2. Higher tiers earn more: Bestie members get 2 extra points per $1 and VIPP members 4 extra.

  • Profile bonus: 1,000 points, worth $2, the first time you complete your profile.
  • Donations: double points on donations to PetSmart Charities at checkout.
  • Expiry: points expire one year after you earn them, unless an offer says otherwise.
  • Bonus offers: activate offers in your account for multiplied points on selected items.

You must be signed in to Treats Rewards at checkout to get the Autoship discount at PetSmart, so join before your first order.

Chewy shipping and returns

As of October 2026, Chewy ships orders over $49 free, usually in 1 to 3 days; orders under $49 cost $4.95 to ship, and first-time customers get free delivery on orders over $35. Chewy accepts returns within 365 days of the sale date and pays the return shipping, which makes trying a new food much less risky.

Putting food and litter in the same order is the easiest way to clear the $49 line without buying anything extra. Start a Chewy return by chat or phone rather than shipping the item back on your own.

Buy the right size and compare price per unit

Larger bags of food usually cost less per pound, but only buy a size your pet will finish while it is fresh. Compare the price per pound or per count rather than per bag, check the best by date, and store opened food in an airtight container. The same rule applies to litter, treats and pads.

  1. Look at the unit price on the product page or shelf tag.
  2. Check how long the bag will last at your pet's daily amount.
  3. Choose the largest size you will use before the best by date.
  4. Put that size on Autoship so the discount applies every time.

The same unit-price habit works in the supermarket, as our guide to saving on groceries explains.

Smart swaps that save money

Some of the biggest savings come from small changes: store brands for litter and basic supplies, fewer but tougher toys, and preventive care that avoids larger vet bills later. Ask your veterinarian before changing your pet's food or medication, because a cheaper option is only a saving if it suits your pet.

  • Store brands: many retailers sell their own litter, pads and supplies for less.
  • Durable toys: one tough toy can outlast several cheap ones.
  • Preventive care: regular checkups and dental care help avoid bigger bills.
  • Group purchases: combine orders for several pets into one Autoship to clear free shipping lines.

Save on pet medication

Online pet pharmacies can cost less than buying at the clinic, but you need your vet's prescription. Ask your vet whether a generic version is available, and compare the price at the clinic, Chewy Pharmacy and other pharmacies. Never change medication or diet just to save money without checking with your veterinarian first.

Our Black Friday game plan helps if you want to stock up on non-perishable supplies during big sales.

Pet supplies FAQ

Is Chewy Autoship worth it?

For food, litter and other items you buy on a schedule, usually yes. As of October 2026, Chewy gives 35% off your first Autoship order, up to $20, then an extra 5% off eligible items on later Autoship orders. You can change, skip or cancel deliveries at any time, so you are not locked in.

Is PetSmart Autoship better than Chewy Autoship?

The discounts are the same, 35% off the first order up to $20 and 5% after, as of October 2026. PetSmart adds Treats Rewards points, 10 per $1 plus 2,500 bonus points for every $100 of recurring Autoship, which can make it worth more over a year. Chewy offers free shipping over $49 and a 365-day return window.

Does Chewy have free shipping?

Yes. As of October 2026, Chewy ships orders over $49 for free, and orders under $49 cost $4.95 to ship. First-time customers get free delivery on orders over $35. Putting food and litter into one order is an easy way to reach the free shipping minimum without buying anything extra.

Are bigger bags of pet food cheaper?

Per pound, larger bags usually cost less, but only buy a size your pet will finish before the food goes stale. Check the best by date, compare the price per pound rather than the price per bag, and store opened food in an airtight container to keep it fresh.

Some links in this guide are affiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.